If know anything about WH Mcleod, youll know hes well versed in many religions, and his forte, is to learn about unknown religions and bring them to a forefront of western thought.

He is based in austrilia, and has a high knowledge of African and Indian studies, and his books, are mainly in the direction of Sikhism and other Indian subcontient religions.

The difference between Mcleod and Maculiffe, is that Mcleod is a student and is bringing education to others. Whereas, Maculiffe was hired for a purpose, and changed many aspects of Gurbani.

What Gurbani did singh5 offer? Are you kidding me? Are we reading the same thread.

If you dont trust wikipedia, than all you have to do is go on google search sikhism and dharma and vedism and read the results, simple.

I am not trying to inspire change, its impossible, i am pointing out obvious ignorant flaws.

Funny thing is, a thread started off to better understand sikhi turned into a slandering of me, then we wonder why sikh youth are at the laughing end of social activism.

I said nothing offensive and was slandered first