Sukhvinder,

Maybe I shouldnt have use those words, but Bhindranwale in my opinion, dead or alive was a horrible person. The Indian government, and people like jagish tyler are just as dispicable and disgusting, They both believed in the same methods of dealing with a problem. As much as I crtitisize the Indian government, Bhindranwale is just as bad. They were both wrong. he is not a shaeed in my opinion, he was a divider, a divider amongst sikhi and amongst the world. He insult nirankari`s, abused non-sikhs and was not a good representative of our community. People only consider him a matyr because of their egos. Because they think that they want to bump their chest, and hold their fists high, and pretend as if he somehow assisted our dharam, when he lead sikhi into its problems today.

That mentality of people want a new land, when we as sikhs already in a horrible situation. So much fighting within sikhi, so much poverty by man made dealers, the drugs, the alcohol, we cant even handle our own dharam, and he wants people to believe that we can handle a country. Disgusting, he took away from sikh values. The Indian government and jagdish tyler wants us to believe that the people who committted 84 have seen their wrong. HE IS AN IDIOT. He must realize that until we dont recieve retribution for 1984, we will never be completely statistfied with the situation of India.

I, as a gursikh, would have never done what Bhindranwale did. What did he do? WHAT WAS HIS EFFECT? People before him told him they knew what was going to come out of this movement of ahankars. DEATH. WHAT HAPPENED IN HARIMANDIR SAHIB, IN 1984, IN A DECADE IN PUNJAB? Im not saying that it is his fault, I am saying that he brought violence to a peaceful religion. Again I look at sikhs, and how we can better our society not some elitist hindus, thats for them to worry about.

 

Amarinder,

I never saw that movie, or heard about the mobile joke, assuming that it is true, its disgusting. But you keep on telling me situations in which I can respond with to. Stories in punjab where sikh majorities and how they handled hindu miniroties, they are immense.

All I am saying is that religion doesnt dictate the whole person. There are more good than bads in hinduism, sikhism, buddhism, etc... You want to assume every hindu is bad unless they are from Punjab, canada, america etc... I think thats wrong.

 

You never address that issue, of how you can generalize a religion with how many hundreds of millions of people.. Do you understand?

To further better others, you must better yourself first brother.

 

Summinder Singh